How do you decide which edtech and AI tools earn a place in your classrooms? Leaders are asking this question as budgets tighten. Vendors arrive with polished demos and promises of fast gains. Meanwhile, purchasing windows close quickly, and the pressure to act grows each week.
The scale of the challenge keeps growing. LearnPlatform by Instructure found that districts accessed an average of 2,982 distinct edtech tools during the 2024–25 school year (Instructure, 2025). Many of those tools never went through a formal review. Each unvetted tool adds another privacy risk, another login, and another invoice.
So where do well-meaning leaders go wrong? Often, we buy the demo instead of the evidence. A teacher loves a free app, and it spreads across a campus before anyone reads the terms. A grant deadline looms, and a contract gets signed after one meeting. Then the renewal arrives at a price far above the pilot.
The Consortium for School Networking’s 2026 State of EdTech report shows how wide the gaps remain. Only 29 percent of district vetting processes ask whether a product is inclusive and accessible (Coffey, 2026). Just over half require vendors to provide safety information. Our review habits have not kept pace with the market.
There is another gap, and it is harder to measure. Many reviews stall the moment someone raises a concern the tool’s champion does not want to hear. I know that from my own experience.
Several years ago, I had a conversation with a colleague that went sideways. Instead of listening, I spent the time defending my position. When we finished, we were both frustrated. We had talked at each other instead of with each other.
Later that day, I went back to see my colleague and apologized for not hearing their point of view. For the next 30 minutes, I stopped arguing and listened. We did not resolve the issue that afternoon. Still, I left understanding why my colleague felt so strongly.
At our next meeting, I brought a restructured proposal that addressed those concerns. By the end, we both agreed on a plan to resolve the issue. Did I know better than to dig in? Of course I did, but I am human, and so is every person on a review team.
Procurement asks us to make that same turn. The special education coordinator who questions screen reader support is handing you information you need. The finance officer asking about year-three pricing is protecting your classrooms. Build a standing review team with voices from curriculum, technology, finance, legal, and special education. Then hold every product to five checks drawn from the EdTech Quality Collaborative’s guidance (Digital Promise et al., 2026).
- Demand evidence that fits your students. Ask vendors which ESSA evidence tier their research meets, then request the full study. The tiers range from strong evidence down to a research-based rationale (ISTE, 2024). A study from a different setting with different students may not transfer to your schools.
- Verify accessibility before adoption. Federal rules under ADA Title II require web content and mobile apps to meet WCAG 2.1 Level AA. Districts serving populations of 50,000 or more must comply by April 26, 2027, and smaller ones by April 26, 2028 (McIntosh, 2026). Request the vendor’s accessibility report, then test the tool with students who use assistive technology.
- Require interoperability with your systems. Ask whether the product follows open data standards and connects cleanly to the systems you already use (ISTE, 2024). Tools that cannot share rosters or grades create manual work for teachers. They also scatter duplicate copies of student data across more servers.
- Read the privacy terms before the price sheet. Ask vendors to sign the National Data Privacy Agreement or your state’s version (Access 4 Learning Community, 2024). For AI tools, ask whether student inputs are used to train the vendor’s models. Confirm data minimization, breach notification timelines, and data deletion when the contract ends.
- Calculate the cost beyond year one. Pilot pricing rarely reflects what renewal will look like. Compare the projected total cost against actual student usage data. Before you sign, ask the vendor to put these figures in writing:
- Renewal pricing for years two through five.
- Training, integration, and support fees.
- Any cost to export your data if you leave.
“One of the biggest powers we have is procurement, so getting serious about how we buy them, and when.” -Keith Krueger, CEO, Consortium for School Networking
When we use that power well, teachers receive tools that work, and families gain reasons to trust us. Which tool in your current inventory would pass all five checks today? And whose concerns about it have you not yet heard?
Start this month with the contracts already on your desk. Pull your next ten renewals and run each one through the five checks. Ask your review team to score them together, and start with the hardest questions. Then share the findings publicly, so families see how decisions get made.
Before you approve your next edtech or AI purchase, gather your review team, hear every concern, and apply these five checks.
#EducationalLeader,
Kim
When schools are well led, students learn well.
References
- Access 4 Learning Community. (2024, April 24). Student Data Privacy Consortium (SDPC) announce the release of the National Data Privacy Agreement, version 2.
- Coffey, L. (2026, June 2). Report: School IT officials worried about AI adoption, cybersecurity. EdSurge.
- Digital Promise, 1EdTech, CAST, CoSN, ISTE, & SETDA. (2026). EdTech quality indicators guide: Leveraging the five edtech quality indicators to save time and money, reduce risk, and improve student outcomes. Digital Promise.
- Instructure. (2025, June 30). New LearnPlatform by Instructure report shows K-12 districts are more selective about edtech tools as they face budget crisis [Press release].
- ISTE. (2024, June 23). Easing the burden on schools: Five quality indicators for edtech & AI products.
- McIntosh, A. (2026, April 22). 5 things K–12 districts should know about ADA Title II compliance. EdTech: Focus on K–12.

0 comments